
There are moments when a community reaches a crossroads – not because of outside hostility, but because of choices made from within. What we are witnessing now with New Square is one of those moments. And make no mistake: this marks a new low.
A plumbing company, operating openly and without hesitation, has now put in writing what many have long suspected but few expected to see stated so plainly: projects within a one-mile radius of New Square are off-limits. Not for technical reasons. Not for capacity. Not for legality. Simply because of where they are located.
This is not subtle. This is not implied. This is explicit Sinas Chinam – spoken clearly, without shame, and with the confidence of people who believe they are protected by something larger than themselves.
And that is precisely the problem.
This Is Bigger Than One Company
Yes, the company deserves to be named and called out for what it chose to say and do. But focusing on them alone would be a mistake. They are not the architects of this behavior. They are the product of it.
This mindset did not appear overnight. It is the result of years of indoctrination – of teaching people that exclusion is righteous, that collective punishment is acceptable, and that sinas chinam can be reframed as moral clarity.
It cannot.
What makes this especially disturbing is not merely the violation of secular law or basic business ethics – though those matters a great deal. It is the open violation of Torah values. The normalization of hatred. The quiet pride in drawing lines that degrade, exclude, and humiliate fellow Jews.
That is not strength. That is rot.
Leadership Owns This – Fully
Let us be absolutely clear: this rests squarely on the shoulders of New Square’s leadership.
Their silence speaks volumes.
Despite widespread awareness, despite meetings with Askanim, despite growing outrage and documented fallout, there has been no meaningful statement, no denial, no correction, no moral reckoning. And based on what leadership has spoken out in small groups, the message is unmistakable: they will only back off if they are left with no choice.
Not because it is wrong
Not because it violates halacha
Not because it damages Klal Yisrael
But because they are forced
That is not leadership. That is damage control delayed.
A Chilling Signal
The most frightening part is not the discrimination itself – it is what it signals. It tells every Skver chossid, every business owner, every young person watching that this behavior is acceptable. That it is encouraged. That it is virtuous.
And once that lesson takes root, the damage is generational.
Communities are judged not only by what they say, but by what they allow. Silence in the face of injustice is not neutrality – it is endorsement.
This Scheme Has Reached Its End
This effort – whatever name it is cloaked in, whatever justification is offered – has reached its breaking point. It has crossed from quiet coercion into open declaration. From whispered policy into written proof.
And that changes everything.
Bad PR should have ended this already. Fact-checking should have ended this already. Fear of repercussions should have ended this already. A basic fear of chilul Hashem should have ended this already.
It did not.
So others will.
Those who care about Torah.
Those who care about justice.
Those who refuse to accept hatred as policy.
We are prepared to continue standing up – calmly, firmly, relentlessly – until this scheme is not only folded, but publicly acknowledged as wrong and declared over.
Because anything less would mean surrendering to evil and allowing hundreds of families to continue suffering real and avoidable harm.
6 Comments
Can they be sued?
Sued for what? We’re allowed to pick and choose which projects we bid on!
True you can deny, ‘But’ you cannot deny based on religion i.e. radious mile of new square which would easily be interpreted by the court as religious bias.
If you fight them without using Halacha, you will lose. Even if you win in court.
There is no Halachic basis to sue, the company is doing nothing halachically wrong. Even as the entire idea of forbidding people to live in ‘the mile’ is wrong.
(Btw, the people from ‘the mile’ buy in NS stores, and the economy of NS gains tremendously from their moving there.)
Sad that this company is brainwashed into believing this is the right way to do business. I feel sorry for them, falling prey to the backward and paranoid ways of Skver. I hope it doesn’t bite this specific business, but I hope it’s a wake-up call for Skver leadership as to how they are ruining their name and dissociating themselves from the rest of Klal Yisrael.
I understand this company’s fear of operating within the mile, the skver vaad is very overpowering and intimidating, especially around this area.